- Page 1 of 1
The Graveyard
/
CG Challenge Archive
PC - MODELLING STAGE VOTING! (Oct 3 - Oct 6)
-
04 Oct 2005Here's where you can vote for your favorite character model!
The voting is going to be a bit different this time round....instead of listing your favourite entry for the 1st, 2nd and 3rd place positions...you're going to give them a sort of "score".
Basically, look at each model and give it a rating out of 10 for the following catagories:
Creativity (is it original?)
Design (is it well modelled?)
Cool (does it look cool overall???)
So....if Bob, John and Carl enter, I would vote (by making a post in this thread) like this:
BOB
Creativity: 8
Design: 6
Cool: 9
JOHN
Creativity: 4
Design: 10
Cool: 7
etc etc
The votes for each entrant will then be tallied and the winner(s) (1st, 2nd and 3rd place) will be announced.
Hope everyone understands that....so go ahead and vote!!!
HERE ARE THE OFFICIAL ENTRIES FOR THE MODELLING PHASE
(I'm only including the ones that were finished in time for the deadline.....if you finished in time but did not get a chance to upload a final picture of your model before I started this voting thread....PM ME and I'll add you to the list of entrants
)
Ben
Jacques
Cam
Idaeus
Tyson
-
04 Oct 2005Also...you may not vote for your own entry!
-
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 6
Design : 5
Cool : 7
Jacques
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 10
Cam
Creativity : 8
Design : 5
Cool : 7
Tyson
Creativity : 6
Design : 8
Cool : 10
Idaeus
Creativity : 9
Design : 5
Cool : 7
-
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 5
Design : 4
Cool : 7
Jacques
Creativity : 8
Design : 6
Cool : 5
Cam
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 10
Tyson
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 10
Idaeus
Creativity : 4
Design : 5
Cool : 6 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 6
Design : 7
Cool : 7
Jacques
Creativity : 6
Design : 6
Cool : 8
Tyson
Creativity : 6
Design : 8
Cool : 8
Idaeus
Creativity : 2
Design : 4
Cool : 4 -
Animare 51 posts04 Oct 2005Gah i screwed up on this challange sorry guys
Great entries
Ben
Creativity : 7
Design : 4
Cool : 7
Jacques
Creativity : 5
Design : 5
Cool : 5
Cam
Creativity : 8
Design : 6
Cool : 8
Tyson
Creativity : 6
Design : 8
Cool : 7
Idaeus
Creativity : 5
Design : 2
Cool : 5 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 4
Design : 5
Cool : 8
Jacques
Creativity : 7
Design : 8
Cool : 7
Cam
Creativity : 9
Design : 9
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 8
Design : 9
Cool : 8
Idaeus
Creativity : 2
Design : 2
Cool : 3 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 7
Design : 8
Cool : 7
Jacques
Creativity : 6
Design : 7
Cool : 7
Cam
Creativity : 9
Design : 8
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 8
Idaeus
Creativity : 5
Design : 5
Cool : 5 -
Kieran 57 posts04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity: 7
Design: 7
Cool: 7
Jaque
Creativity: 8
Design: 7
Cool: 8
Cam
Creativity: 9
Design: 7
Cool: 8
Idaeus
Creativity: 5
Design: 6
Cool: 6
Tyson
Creativity: 8
Design: 9
Cool: 8
Most scores fairly close from me, good work folks.
-Kieran -
Simon Dennis 1 posts04 Oct 2005hey guys, new to the new forum, but i was told i should vote
love contests!
Ben
Creativity :8
Design : 4
Cool : 9
Jacques
Creativity : 7
Design : 7
Cool : 5
Cam
Creativity : 8
Design : 7
Cool : 8
Tyson
Creativity : 7
Design : 9
Cool : 7
Idaeus
Creativity : 4
Design : 5
Cool : 4 -
04 Oct 2005Wow! Thanks everyone for voting! I wasn't sure how this new system would work but in less than a day many of you have already mastered it!!!
As for me:
Ben
Creativity: 7
Design: 7
Cool: 9
Jacques:
Creativity: 8
Design: 6
Cool: 7
Cam:
Creativity: 10 (hahaha peg leg!)
Design: 8
Cool: 10
Idaeus:
Creativity: 3
Design: 2
Cool: 4
I'll tally up the votes once the voting deadline passes (ie...after Oct 6) -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity :8
Design : 8
Cool : 9
Cam
Creativity : 10
Design : 8
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 9
Idaeus
Creativity : 5
Design : 4
Cool : 5 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity :10
Design : 10
Cool : 10
Jaques
Creativity : 6
Design : 6
Cool : 6
Cam
Creativity : 9
Design : 9
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 8
Design : 8
Cool : 8
Idaeus
Creativity : 3
Design : 3
Cool : 3 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 7
Design : 6
Cool : 8
Jacques
Creativity : 8
Design : 7
Cool : 9
Cam
Creativity : 8
Design : 7
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 10
Design : 9
Cool : 10
Idaeus
Creativity : 6
Design : 4
Cool : 5 -
04 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity: 9
Design: 9
Cool: 9
Jacques
Creativity: 8
Design: 6
Cool: 8
Cam
Creativity: 10
Design: 9
Cool: 9
Idaeus
Creativity: 7
Design: 5
Cool: 5
Tyson
Creativity: 9
Design: 9
Cool: 9 -
05 Oct 2005NOTE! Just so everyone knows, JAKE has contacted me letting me know that his entry was finished on time but he didn't get a chance to upload it in time (same with Andrew it seems)....
SO ....
Take note of this thread because I'm going to edit the original post (and include their entries) and then all you'll have to do is edit your vote posts to include scores for those 2 entries.
For future contests I'm going to see if we can't have a little more buffer time between posting final images and voting, to avoid this bit of confusion
In the meantime...thanks for your understanding and make sure you check back here to vote for the last 2 once they're uploaded! -
05 Oct 2005Jaque
Creativity: 9
Design: 7
Cool: 8
Cam
Creativity: 8
Design: 8
Cool: 9
Idaeus(because it's evil)
Creativity: 6
Design: 6
Cool: 6
Tyson(you're too good!
)
Creativity: 1
Design: 1
Cool: 1
Tyson's real judgement:
Creativity: 8
Design: 10
Cool: 9 -
05 Oct 2005My votes:
Ben
Creativity: 8
Design: 8
Cool: 9
Jacques:
Creativity: 7
Design: 6
Cool: 6
Cam
Creativity: 8
Design: 8
Cool: 7
Idaeus
Creativity: 6
Design: 6
Cool: 7.5
Tyson
Creativity: 8
Design: 9
Cool: 8 -
05 Oct 2005OK EVERYONE....here are Jake's and Andrew's entries!
INSTEAD OF EDITING YOUR POST.....just reply with another post stating both of their scores.
Andrew
Jake
-
05 Oct 2005Andrew
Creativity: 8
Design: 7
Cool: 8
Jake
Creativity: 6
Design: 8
Cool: 9 -
05 Oct 2005Andrew
Creativity: 8
Design: 8
Cool: 9 -
troubadour 207 posts05 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity:9
Design:9
Cool:9
Jaques
Creativity:8
Design:7
Cool:7
Cam
Creativity:10
Design:8
Cool:9
Idaeus
Creativity:6
Design:5
Cool:6
Tyson
Creativity:8
Design:9
Cool:9
Andrew
Creativity:8
Design:7
Cool:9
Jake
Creativity:7
Design:8
Cool:9 -
05 Oct 2005Andrew
Creativity:9
Design:6
Cool:9
Jake
Creativity:10
Design:10
Cool:10 -
05 Oct 2005Jake
Creativity:7
Design:8
Cool:10
Andrew
Creativity:10
Design:8
Cool:9 -
05 Oct 2005Jake
Creativity:6
Design:8
Cool:9
Andrew
Creativity:6
Design:7
Cool:8 -
skriblur 5 posts05 Oct 2005 -
05 Oct 2005Ok people....
We still need:
onno
john
simon
kieran
weider
grafi
and aden
to vote on Andrew and Jake's entries! Luckily the voting only ends in 2 days...so you've still got a bit of time before we have to hunt you down -
Animare 51 posts05 Oct 2005Jake
Creativity:8
Design:7
Cool:7
Andrew
Creativity:7
Design:7
Cool:7 -
05 Oct 2005Andrew
Creativity:7
Design:7
Cool:8
Jake
Creativity:7
Design:9
Cool:9
Hey look! I got an 8 from skriblur for my name! Awesome! -
05 Oct 2005Andrew
Creativity: 10
Design: 7
Cool: 8
Jake
Creativity: 7
Design: 8
Cool: 9
ps: i didnt vote until this morning because i had a late night last ngiht with a couple of friends and didnt have time to check back on the forum :_: -
06 Oct 2005Sorry for being late for voting::
Ben
Creativity:9
Design:9
Cool:10 ( i like this a lot)
Jaques
Creativity:7
Design:7
Cool:7
Cam
Creativity:7
Design:8
Cool:8
Idaeus
Creativity:6
Design:5
Cool:6
Tyson
Creativity:8
Design:7
Cool:7 (looks like naked to me
)
Andrew
Creativity:8
Design:7
Cool:9
Jake
Creativity:7
Design:8
Cool:9 -
07 Oct 2005Ok...well I'll give those who didn't get a chance to vote for the last 2 entries (even though they voted for the first 5) until this evening (my time...whenever that is lol) to vote
-
07 Oct 2005Okay....
THE WINNER FOR THE MODELLING ROUND IS:
Cam!
THE 2ND PLACER IS:
Jake
THE 3RD PLACER IS:
Tyson (me! yaay!)
Great job everyone!....Congrats to the winners of this round!
Here are the scores for all of the entrants:
(by the way....for those last 2 entrants that got in late...ie...Jake and Andrew....and therefore were left out of some people's votes.....I simply averaged out what everyone else voted for them, and compensated their scores with the addition of that value for everyone that didn't vote for them but voted for the others....make sense?)
Cam: 426
Jake: 418
Tyson: 409
Andrew: 401
Ben: 386
Jacques: 361
Idaeus: 247.5
Once again....Great job everyone!!!
*if I mis-counted on any of the scores please feel free to correct me -
07 Oct 2005Woooooooh!
-
07 Oct 2005i may have came last but im happy that i got the score i did, i was expecting something in double figures , so im pleased,
-
troubadour 207 posts07 Oct 2005
-
07 Oct 2005
-
11 Oct 2005Ben
Creativity : 7
Design : 4
Cool : 8
Jacques
Creativity : 7
Design : 8
Cool : 10
Cam
Creativity : 9
Design : 6
Cool : 7
Idaeus
Creativity : 5
Design : 8
Cool : 9
Tyson
Creativity : 9
Design : 8
Cool : 7
Andrew
Creativity : 9
Design : 9
Cool : 10
Jake
Creativity : 7
Design : 8
Cool : 10
- Page 1 of 1
Simply CG Contributors
